I recently saw that Oreo came out with another new flavor, Key Lime Pie Oreo. A graham flavored cookie with a key lime pie creme filling. I was intrigued! I honestly haven’t tried it yet but immediately thought of my favorite Homemade Graham Cracker recipe and thought how fun it would be to make my own Key Lime Pie Oreo.
I made a batch of my Graham Crackers only changing a couple of things. I rolled it out a little thinner because it does rise a little and baked it for a couple minutes less because of that. It turned out so yummy as usual! Using a small circle cutter, I got about 56 graham cracker circles out of it. So this recipe makes about 28 Key Lime Pie Oreos.
Next, I made the key lime creme filling. It was so easy! I just mixed up a little butter and powdered sugar, then added lime zest and lime juice. That is IT! I know this is key lime but I couldn’t find it at my grocery store so limes work just as great too! I piped on the filling onto the graham cracker cookies then pressed the tops on until the filling reached the edges. It was oh so delicious! The graham crackers have such a depth of delicious flavor to them and the key lime creme filling has the perfect amount of creaminess and lime flavor to it.
I put some in the fridge and had another one a few hours later and enjoyed that as well. If you want the filling to be firmer then I would recommend chilling these after you assemble them.
Key Lime Pie Creme
You might also like: